Best Whitening Toothpaste: A Guide to Popular Brands and Natural Options

0 Shares

The best whitening toothpaste is a hot topic for discussion in the cosmetic dentistry industry these days. It seems like everywhere you look—magazines, movies, the office—you’re surrounded by perfectly white teeth.

what is the best whitening toothpaste
Can a toothpaste help you whiten teeth?

It wasn’t always that way though—have you watched a Robert DeNiro movie from the 70s or 80s recently? Well, the next time you do, take a look at all of the actors’ teeth. Not bad, but not exceptionally good like they are nowadays either.

Thanks to countless innovations in cosmetic dentistry, there are a plethora of ways for you to achieve a smile that looks like the ‘after’ in a set of ‘before and after’ smile transformation photos.

And one of the seemingly easiest ways advertised to get flawlessly white teeth? Simply by brushing your teeth with toothpaste. But does toothpaste really work? And what is the best teeth whitening toothpaste?

We’ll answer your burning questions as well as go over the following information:

  • Best natural whitening toothpaste
  • Best charcoal toothpaste for whitening
  • Best whitening toothpaste for sensitive teeth

So keep reading to become a fully informed consumer!

What is whitening toothpaste?

Toothpaste that is advertised to whiten teeth is just like a normal toothpaste, but the difference is that it is made to promote teeth whitening. This is nothing new, in fact like many Americans, you may have been using whitening toothpastes for years without even realizing it. It’s hard to avoid them, and you certainly won’t find any that are advertised as not whitening.

In fact, the concept of whitening toothpastes is a great idea. Our teeth are constantly being bombarded with things that can turn them yellow. Even if you brush your teeth regularly and with the proper brushing technique, a healthy diet is full of foods that can stain. Think about the blueberries you eat with your cereal in the morning, or the glass of red you have with dinner at night.

And as for you coffee drinkers and you smokers with yellow teeth, well you know what I’m talking about.

But, realistically, if you’re not going to be giving up blueberries or cigarettes any time soon, many products can be a great help.

Does whitening toothpaste really work?

Excellent question! The truth is that despite their ubiquitousness in the global toothpaste market, whitening toothpastes haven’t been shown to make a huge difference in the whiteness of teeth.

Now, that doesn’t mean they should be totally discounted, we said they don’t make a ‘huge’ difference, not they don’t make ‘any’ difference.

According to the Mayo Clinic, shoutout to Minne-snow-ta, whitening toothpastes can whiten teeth slightly by removing surface stains, like those caused by the foods you eat, the cigarettes you smoke, or the coffee you drink. The big ‘but’ however is that these sorts of whitening toothpastes aren’t able to change the natural color of your teeth, and they can’t erase discoloration that is underneath the surface of your tooth.

So to remove surface stains, by all means, use a whitening toothpaste. We have a section further down in this article about the brands on the market that will work the best at removing these surface stains, thus giving your teeth a whiter appearance.

For anything below the surface, you’ll want to consider some other teeth whitening options, which we will also go over further down.

Watch this video to see a dentist talk about the actual whitening abilities of toothpaste.

How does it work?

We mentioned above that whitening toothpastes work to remove surface stains from your teeth. But, how do they do this?

Whitening toothpastes are normally abrasive, and this actually helps to polish stains off. Although too much abrasiveness can be a bad thing, as it could wear down your enamel. And if it does that, your teeth will actually appear to be yellower, because dentin, the stuff under your enamel, is naturally yellow in color!

These pastes can also contain peroxide and other chemicals that will break down, dissolve and whiten stains.

Some toothpastes contain something called blue covarine. This doesn’t actually help to get rid of stains, instead it coats the teeth, creating the appearance of whiteness—so although it works instantly, it’s quite superficial.

Other ways to whiten teeth

professional teeth whitening
A more effective way to whiten teeth may be offered by your dentist

Since whitening toothpastes aren’t always the most effective way to whiten your teeth, you may also want to consider some other options.

Some of the most effective ways to whiten teeth include:

Professional bleaching: This affordable teeth whitening procedure is offered by dentists. Custom trays are made to fit your teeth and are then used to apply a professional grade tooth whitening gel, meaning that it’s stronger than anything you can get at home. You have to go to the dentist to get your trays made and to receive your brightening gel, but the actual procedure is done in the comfort of your home, sometimes overnight. You can ask your dentist about all of your options.

Strips: Many people who want to whiten their teeth choose teeth whitening strips because you can buy them online or over-the-counter. They are also very easy to use and not messy, as the actual strips are simply placed over teeth for the instructed amount of time. Strips are a great solution for an upcoming event, as they don’t cost too much, work quickly and are easy to use.

Lasers: Laser teeth whitening is a procedure that uses lasers to speed up the whitening effect of a gel applied to the teeth. You can get this done at the dentist’s. This sort of treatment is safe, effective…and usually expensive. But if you’ve got the dough to blow, go for it!

Best whitening toothpaste

Now that you’ve learned a bit more about some other effective teeth whitening options, let’s get back to why you’re really here: whitening toothpaste. We’ve searched the vast stretches of the World Wide Web to create a list of the best toothpaste for whitening teeth. You can see a summary of these products in the table below, and then continue reading for a deep dive into each one.

Toothpaste Image Best... Special features Price
Crest 3D White Brilliance Overall Two-step toothpaste and whitening gel
Colgate Optic White Overall Hydrogen peroxide
Tom's of Maine Antiplaque and Whitening Natural Natural ingredients like zinc citrate and xylitol, fluoride-free
Cali White Activated Charcoal and Coconut Oil Activated-charcoal Fluoride-free
Sensodyne Pronamel Gentle Whitening Sensitive teeth Strengthens enamel
Arm & Hammer Advance White Baking soda Dental-grade baking soda

Best overall: Crest and Colgate

Crest 3D White Brilliance

best whitening toothpaste
A 2-step system may be the most effective

Crest 3D White may actually be cheating a bit with this whitening toothpaste because it’s not actually just a toothpaste—it’s a process that involves two steps:

  1. Deep cleaning toothpaste
  2. Whitening finisher

First, you brush your teeth as you normally would with toothpaste, only for one minute instead of two minutes. And then you brush for another minute with the whitening finisher. And lastly, you rinse. Crest actually claims that by using this product every day, your teeth will be 99% as clean as they are after a professional polish.

This toothpaste uses a combination of hydrogen peroxide and sodium hydroxide to whiten teeth, and 0.24% sodium fluoride to fight decay.

One happy customer says:

“The only toothpaste I use now. I use to have yellow teeth because they stain easily but now, especially right after brushing, I have a pearly white smile”

Colgate Optic White

best toothpaste for whitening teeth
Optic White is beloved by many reviewers

We had to include two whitening toothpastes in the best toothpaste for teeth whitening “overall category” because consumers seem to be torn between Crest and Colgate on this one.

Some swear by Colgate Optic White as the best tooth whitening toothpaste. This toothpaste claims to give you a visibly whiter smile if used as directed for at least four weeks and that by the end of just one week with regular use, you’ll already notice a brighter smile.

To achieve brighter and whiter teeth, this product uses the whitening powers of hydrogen peroxide to go beyond surface stains and tackle discoloring that you’ve struggled with for a long time. It’s also safe for daily use as it won’t wear down your enamel.

One reviewer expresses their love for this product by saying:

“This is the most effective whitening toothpaste out there. I’ve used this toothpaste daily for five years. It keeps my teeth nice and bright. “

Best natural toothpaste for white teeth: Tom’s of Maine

For those of you who want whiter teeth, but don’t want to give up your natural oral hygiene routine, you may want to try Tom’s of Maine Antiplaque and Whitening toothpaste.

best natural whitening toothpaste
Naturally whiten teeth with Tom’s

It features natural toothpaste ingredients like zinc citrate and xylitol for whitening teeth; these ingredients also keeping them free from plaque and preventing cavities, and a natural peppermint flavor to freshen breath.

As with all of Tom’s products, this one has never been tested on animals and meets high standards of social and environmental performance.

There is an overwhelming amount of positive reviews on Amazon for this product, however, the reviewers mostly seem to see the whitening as an afterthought, or they don’t mention it at all. Mainly they like this product for its natural ingredients, with one reviewer saying:

“I’m trying to eliminate all the sources of fluoride I can from my daily life. This toothpaste helps with that. My teeth are cleaned very well with this, showing you certainly don’t need fluoride for that. It seems to “whiten” as well as any other whitening toothpaste. For real whitening, you have to see your dentist for a treatment or use trays with gel or whitening strips.”

Best activated charcoal toothpaste for whitening: Cali White

Best charcoal toothpaste for whitening
Activated charcoal is a current favorite

If you’ve been anywhere accept for under a rock lately, you’ve probably heard of the whole activated charcoal teeth-whitening trend. Well, you too can join the activated charcoal movement by trying Cali White Activated Charocal and Coconut Oil toothpaste.

This teeth whitening toothpaste includes nature’s best ingredients that work to remove stains like:

  • active carbon
  • organic coconut oil
  • baking soda

It’s also made in the US, is vegan, SLS-free and fluoride-free so you can check off all of your sustainability boxes and know that you’re doing your part for the environment and your oral health when you use it.

And unlike other charcoal varieties that aren’t big on flavor, this activated charcoal whitening paste has a Pacific Mint flavor that gets rid of bad breath and leaves your mouth feeling refreshed. The flavor comes from xylitol and peppermint oil, so no artificial flavors either.

One happy customer says:

“My teeth look WHITE! I love all the good ingredients and it makes me feel super clean. I enjoy how it gets black and then the “reveal” of my white teeth when I rinse :)”

Best whitening for sensitive teeth: Sensodyne

best whitening toothpaste for sensitive teeth
Rebuild enamel while you brighten your smile

Just because you have sensitive teeth doesn’t mean you have to settle for a boring toothpaste that doesn’t give you a brighter smile. With Sensodyne Pronamel Gentle Whitening toothpaste you can protect your tooth enamel at the same time that you remove stains, and polish up those pearly whites.

This is the best toothpaste to whiten teeth that are prone to sensibility because it protects tooth enamel from the effects of acidic foods and drinks, along with actually re-hardening enamel that has gone soft. How does it do that? It has an optimized formula that aids those minerals found in saliva, such as calcium, in penetrating your enamel to fortify it. It also has very low abrasiveness so it won’t further weaken your enamel like other more abrasive options might.

Similarly to the Tom’s paste mentioned above, although advertised as a paste that will give you a brighter smile, most reviewers appreciate its focus on sensitivity and protection against decay more than anything, with one reviewer saying:

“It’s really gentle for a whitening toothpaste and it does restore lost enamel which is really important. Very gentle & tastes good.”

Best toothpaste for white teeth with baking soda: Arm & Hammer

best toothpaste whitening baking soda
Baking soda is a popular natural whitener

This is an ingredient often used in natural oral hygiene products and popular name-brand ones as well for its whitening powers. But no other paste is as famous for its use of dental-grade baking soda than Arm & Hammer. And loyal Arm & Hammer customers can get an extra boost to whiten their teeth with their AdvanceWhite toothpaste. Customers love this product because of its:

  • Low-abrasion formula that won’t damage enamel
  • Fluoride to prevent cavities and remove plaque and stains
  • Dental-grade baking soda that keeps your teeth clean and bright

One customer sums up their appreciation for this brand by saying:

“Good oral hygiene is super super important and having a white healthy smile and with that goal in mind, a baking soda based toothpaste is the only way to go and this is one brand that I particularly like for that reason. Not only do my pearly whites feel clean, it’s visibly apparent. Smile 😃. Thank You Arm&Hammer. My number one go to toothpaste for decades and this price point ain’t bad either.”

Conclusion

brushing teeth
Brush your teeth regularly for a healthy smile

Keeping your teeth free of cavities should be your number one priority when it comes to oral hygiene. But if you’ve already got that covered and are looking to also have whiter teeth, adding a special whitening toothpaste to your routine might help. All of the products we mentioned receive overwhelmingly positive reviews, so you’ll just have to try them out for yourself and see which one works for you. But remember, the most important thing when it comes to your oral health is a proper oral hygiene routine that includes regular brushing and flossing.

You can “brush up” on your technique by reading our articles on proper brushing techniques and proper flossing techniques to make sure you’re maximizing your cleaning power.

FAQs

Which Crest toothpaste is best for whitening?

Although most Crest pastes are supposed to help with whitening, for best results, you may want to choose a toothpaste from the Crest 3D White range like this Crest 3D white toothpaste, or the Brilliance set we mentioned above, which includes both a paste and a whitening gel.

Is Crest or Colgate better for whitening?

The jury is out on this one, but they both seem to work for many people to whiten teeth. The main difference is that Crest uses stannous fluoride to fight cavities and gum disease, whereas Colgate uses sodium fluoride. According to this study, stannous fluoride is actually more effective in fighting cavities than sodium fluoride. But ultimately, you’ll have to see which one works best for you.

What is the best whitening toothpaste for sensitive teeth?

The award for this one goes to Sensodyne . It remains the leader in the market when it comes to protecting sensitive teeth and actually helping to rebuild enamel. Will it whiten your teeth? Maybe—the reviews seem to be mixed, but it will certainly help with sensitivity issues.

Rate this article

0 Shares